The Murder of Mattie Hackett

On Thursday evening, August 17, 1905, the idyllic New England town of Readfield, Maine was shaken by the murder of seventeen-year-old Mattie Hackett.

Mattie was the third child of Levi and Edith Hackett. A beloved student of the Maine Wesleyan Seminary & Female College at Kents Hill she was considered a hard worker, affable, learned, and pleasant. On that fated night she was strangled to death only three hundred feet from the barn where her father and a visiting stranger were tending livestock.

Over the next four months the investigators struggle to conclude whether the murder was committed by tramps passing through the town, a jealous woman, or some other unknown character, and by April the following year the county attorney is unable to secure an indictment.

Six years after the murder, an ambitious county attorney candidate promises if elected he will bring the perpetrator of the murder to justice. Elected to office the case is re-opened, re-investigated, subsequently resulting in the indictment and trial of Elsie Raymond.

In this nominally fictionalized tale, the author brings us through the fated evening, the ensuing days, weeks, months, and years through the trial of Elsie Raymond. Using in depth research, the author uses the actual facts and characters to take the reader to 1905 – 1912 Kennebec County, Maine to witness the events and experience the personal moments of those involved.

The murder of Mattie Hackett came to the attention of the author while researching his first book concerning the December, 1905 murder of David Varney in Porter, Maine. The story of Mattie Hackett remains high on the list of Maine’s unsolved murder mysteries. While many essays, news and magazine articles, and even a song!, have been published, The Murder of Mattie Hackett by Peter M. Pettingill is the first full length narrative of the tale.

Purchase The Murder of Mattie Hackett online

The “Murder of Mattie Hackett” took place in Readfield, Maine where I am historian, family researcher and author of historical non-fiction, so I expected to find myself a critic rather than a fan. To the contrary, I was drawn in from page one and impressed with the author’s accurate character development (I recognized all the Readfield names), and the extent of research through court records, news articles, census and other genealogical records. Then, to weave the vast myriad of details into an easy to follow storyline was impressive to say the least. Even though I knew the outcome of the book before I started to read it, I still experienced a mounting element of intrigue as I approached the ending. An unexpected bonus was to find some of my own kin within it pages – my great-grandmother, Isabel who was working the switchboard the night of the murder and her father, John Davis who served on the grand jury. The final section of the book includes short biographies of every major character in the book, which also required a tremendous amount of digging and organization. I very much enjoyed reading “The Murder of Mattie Hackett” and recommend it to anyone who enjoys true crime mysteries, local history or has family roots in Maine as no doubt you will find someone in this book who falls within the realm of six degrees of separation (or less). – Maine History Buff
 
I started to read this book today and have got nothing else done because I cannot put it down. I love history and mysteries. I highly recommend this one! – Marybeth 
 
This is not my preferred genre but I couldn’t put it down and really enjoyed it. Pettingill has a knack for quick repartee and nimble descriptions. I recommend Hackett for mystery lovers, local history buffs, or anyone, really. – Kimberly
 
Although I’m normally not a big murder mystery reader, I thoroughly enjoyed this one. I can’t wait to hand it off to my 12 year old son who is also excited to read it. Being a lifetime New England resident, I enjoyed reading about the towns and places I’ve visited over the years and the visuals of how they once were. – Jim 

Some photographs from the April 19, 2024 Readfield Historical Society history walk.

Pete Pettingill talking about the murder of Mattie Hackett on the P-Ridge Road during the April 19, 2024 Readfield Historical Society history walk.

Pete Pettingill during the April 19, 2024 Readfield Historical Society History Walk standing at the site where Mattie was found.

Dale Potter Clark during the April 19, 2024 Readfield Historical Society history walk.